Comparing, not recommending
Where these facts come from, and what this page will not decide
Every trim, its physical size, its regular-or-large class and its page-count windows are read from Amazon's published paperback trim table for the Amazon KDP, US store (kdp.amazon.com), last compared against that page on 2026-08-27. Other marketplaces publish a different catalogue, and hardcover, custom trims and non-US stores are outside this page.
The page-count window is a fact about a trim AND a print option together, not about a trim alone. All 5 print options are listed under each trim with their own range, because the largest trims accept fewer pages than the rest and one combination is not offered at all. Summarising a trim as a single page range would hide exactly the case that gets a book rejected after it has been typeset.
Nothing is checked against a page count until you say you have a final formatted one — the extent your finished layout reports, not an estimate. Until then every print option reads "page-count fit not checked", which is a different answer from "compatible". An unchecked fact shown as a pass is the failure this page is built to avoid.
There is no best trim here, and no ranking, score or genre advice, because Amazon publishes none and neither do we. The page compares, narrows and explains consequences. A selected trim appears only when you press the button that selects it, it stays selected even when a later constraint contradicts it, and it is never swapped for another one.